In the recent blockbuster movie the Dark Knight, there is a scene where batman is faced with choosing between the life and death of two people. He can either save a girl who was essentially his best friend and love interest, or he can save Gotham City district attorney Harvey Dent. While Batman sends his close friend to save Harvey Dent, he continues to go after his love interest Rachael. The locations of these two hostages are switched unknowingly to batman and he ultimately winds up saving Harvey Dent. His love Rachael, unfortunately could not be reached in time and perishes.
I believe this is a great example of to the extent at which we are held morally responsible for our actions.
Batman was responsible for the fates of two individuals whom he knew were in grave danger. He can not directly be held responsible for the death of Rachael because he tried save both her and Harvey. Moreover, he held the position to save both life’s, whereas, he could just have easily let them die. He didn’t need to do anything. Despite the fact that Rachael died, Batman made the best choice for the life’s of the people in Gotham City. He knew Harvey was important to the City and it’s people, and that Rachael was more of a selfish goal. Batman measured his priorities and decided whatever the outcome may be, that Harvey would be the one who must survive. I believe for reasons like this, that we are only morally responsible for a terrible action if we know beforehand, that it is going to cause more “bad” then “good.”
I believe this also proves that by knowing the consequences of a future outcome, we can “judge” the situation based on Utilitarianism. Batman knew that Harvey Dent was the one person who could improve the quality of life for the citizens of Gotham City. He was more important to them because he was a figurehead of good morals who gave them a sense of security and hope. If batman had saved Rachael, chaos would have ensued, and Gotham City would fall into a life of constant crime and violence.
You must be logged in to post a comment.